Honors 250F-01A: Philosophy of Religion: Theodicies

January  |  February  |  March  |  April  |  May
Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday
Jan 15 1

Intro to Course

16 2

 

17 3

Dostoevsky, chs. 3-4: "The Brothers Make Friends," "Rebellion" pp. 1-17

journal question
Group 1: Public Folder

18 4 19 5

Dostoevsky, ch. 5, "The Grand Inquisitor," pp. 19-37.

journal option
Group 2: Public Folder

22 6 23 1

Dostoevsky, Book VI: "The Russian Monk," pp. 39-80

journal ideas
Group 3 is up!

24 2 25 3

Augustine, Confessions, Bks I-II (3-34)

Open journal
Group 4: Public Folder

26 4

 

Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday
29 5

Augustine, Confessions

Books 3 & 4

30 6   31 1

Augustine, Confessions

Books 5 & 6

February 1 2

 

2 3

Augustine, Confessions

Book 7: Group 1

5 4 6 5

Augustine, Confessions

Books 8-9: Group 2

See essay assignment due Feb.12

7 6


8 1

Aquinas: Summa Theologica (web), Part I, Questions 48, 49
Aquinas Guide

No journal entry

9 2

 

12 3

essay due
paper format

13 4

 

14 5

continue discussion of Aquinas, Q 49

Group 3 - Public Folder

15 6 16 1

Read: in Voltaire, Candide, Leibniz, pp. 84-86; & Theodicy Summary
& Pope, Essay on Man, in Candide, pp. 86-94

Group 4 - Public Folder

19 2

 

20 3

Voltaire, Candide, chs. 1-16, pp. 1-35.

Group 1: Public Folder

21 4

 

22 5

Voltaire, Candide, chs. 17-30, pp. 36-79.

Group 2: Public Folder

23 6

 

F   E   B   R   U   A   R   Y      2   4   --   M   A   R   C   H      4  :      S   P   R   I   N   G         B   R   E   A   K

Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday
March 5 1

start C.S. Lewis
(video in class)

6 2

 

7 3

C.S. Lewis, The Problem of Pain, chs. 1-5 (pp. 1-85)

Public Folder Group 3

8 4

 

9 5

C.S. Lewis: chs. 6-10 (pp. 86-159)
Public Folder: Group 4

No class: Board Meetings

12 6

 

13 1

 Essay #2 due

14

Benedictine Heritage Day: "Dancing on the Edge

15 2

 

 
16 3

 Milton, Paradise Lost, Books 1-2

Public Folder Group 1

19 4

 

20 5

 Milton, Paradise Lost, Books 3-4

 Public Folder Group 2

21 6

 

22 1

 Milton, Paradise Lost, Books 5-6

Public Folder Group 3

23 2

 

26 3

Milton, Paradise Lost, Books 7-9*
NOTE: longer reading

Public Folder Group 4

27 4

 

28 5

Milton, Paradise Lost, Book 10

 

29 6

 

30 1

Milton, Paradise Lost
Books 11-12

Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday
April 2 2

 

3 3

Elie Wiesel, Night

(complete)

4 4

 

5

 E   A   S   T   E   R    

Holy Thursday

6

 B   R   E   A   K

Good Friday

9

 

10 5

Movie: The Quarrel
meet in Quad 346

11 6

 

12 1

finish The Quarrel
Quad 346

13 2

 

16 3  

Annie Dillard, For the Time Being, chs 1-4

Public Folder: Group 1

17 4

 

18 5

 paper due

19 6

 

20 1

Annie Dillard, For the Time Being, finish

Public Folder: Group 2

23 2

 

24 3

Kierkegaard: Fear and Trembling, pp. 3-24

Public Folder: Group 3

25 4

 

26 5  

Kierkegaard: Fear and Trembling, "Problemata: Preamble from the Heart," pp. 27-61.

Public Folder: Group 4

27 6

 

Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday
30 1

Kierkegaard, F&T Problema I: pp. 62-79.

May 1 2

 

2 3

Kierkegaard, F&T Problema II: pp. 80-97.

3 4

 

4 5

Kierkegaard, F&T Problema III: pp. 98-105; 137-148, & Epilogue, 149-152.

7 6

 

8

Study Day

9

Exam Day 1

10

Exam Day 2
Final Paper due

11

Exam Day 3

For:

Wednesday, January 17 (3):

bulletIdeas for journal reflection: How would you respond to Ivan? (You can focus on any of the things he says: his stories, his conclusion, his "philosophy." What do you think of Alyosha's response to him? Other thoughts are welcome as well. You can always, in your journals, discuss what is puzzling or a problem to understand. Don't feel as if you have to be "right" all the time in these.
bulletGroup 1 Public Folder: By 10 PM Tuesday night, choose something from your journal reflections and post it on the public folder. Your journal might be more free-ranging, written for yourself, but this should be intended to prompt class discussion, both electronically and in class.
bulletPublic Folder location: [All] Public Folders - Philosophy - Dennis Beach - Philosophy of Religion
bulletIf you need help: http://www.csbsju.edu/itservices/knowledgebase/data/email/foldersuse.htm
bulletThe rest of the class is free to respond to these reflections in any way you'd like.

Friday, January 19 (5):

bulletThis is the most famous section of Dostoevsky's novel, and there should be lots to discuss (We might extend this section another day). I'll leave you to write about whatever interests you for your journals...
bulletAnd Group 2 (Michelle, Peter, Karla, Luke) should pick up on something from your journal--or something else that strikes you, and propose it as a topic for class discussion by making an entry in the Public Folder. As you propose the topic, at least begin to give your own take on it (200-250 words by 10:00 PM). As always, others can and should respond electronically--at least you need to respond electronically about half the time.

Tuesday, January 23 (1):

bulletOur editor thinks (and I agree) that these chapters, although they come a little later in the novel, are in some ways an answer to the problems posed by Ivan in the "Rebellion" and "The Grand Inquisitor" chapters. They're not a directly argumentative answer, that is, not a debate-type answer, but still in some sense an answer or alternative perspective. You might try to think about how the story of Zossima in any way "responds" to Ivan's points of view. Or you could just pick out your favorite part and comment on that!
bulletTake it away Beth, Mya, Colman and Jordan. Anything you want to write about is fair game for the public folder. And everyone else, remember your promise to read and at least occasionally respond to others' entries. You don't want to have the fleas of a thousand camels infest your armpits!

Thursday, January 25 (3):

bulletWhile I said not to read the Introduction, the short Foreward (xxvii-xxx) might be helpful. It will at least tell you a little bit about Augustine for context. And the "Translator's Note" (xxxi) explains why there are Thee's and Thou's some places and You's everywhere else.
bulletFor journals, I will just suggest you pick out something that interests you to comment on. This is a very different style work than the excerpts form the novel, The Brothers Karamazov. It is rather a spiritual autobiography--perhaps one of the first instances of "autobiography" in literature. It focuses on Augustine's spiritual journey--his conversion really, although books 10-13 turn more to a reflection first on his own state post-conversion, and then on the first book of the Bible, Genesis. We'll focus on the first 8-9 books (really on books 7 & 8), as well as a little section of Augustine's "Handbook" / Enchiridion (web-accessed). But see what piques your interest here.
bulletThe same goes for the Public Folder entries by Kenan, Pat, Hue, and Ellen. I will have some topics I will raise if they aren't raised by you, but I'd rather see what grabs your interest.

Monday, January 29 (5)

bulletRead Augustine Confessions, Books 3-4. Book Three starts out, ""I came to Carthage, where a cauldron of illicit loves boiled about me." Read on! (Actually, you won't get any really salacious passages, sorry. But there are some poignant parts of these chapters. Keep in mind that in much of them, Augustine is about your age. (He starts Book Three at age 16, but is 27 by the end of Book Four). He "goes away to school" as part of this time, starts developing real intellectual interests, begins a "relationship," loses a close friend--all parts of life that could have some resonance. (Not that I suspect you all of having a "cauldron of illicit loves" boiling about you!)
bulletKeep up with your journals--Here I expect a regular reflection on something in the day's reading. Doesn't have to be real long, but the key is to do something with what you read--makes it stick a little more.
bulletNo group is assigned for Public Folder. If anyone wants to make a voluntary entry, that is certainly welcome. Most of you are in the habit of checking the folder, so if someone posts, others may reply. If Hue is feeling better, I've suggested that she post something, so you should at least check for that.

Wednesday, January 31 (1)

bulletKeep up with your journals. Optional Public Folder postings.

Friday, February 2 (3)

bulletGroup 1 should post by 10 PM Thursday night something dealing with Book 7. In this book, Augustine makes a crucial breakthrough in his thought process. His study of Platonic Philosophy is very important for this. You might want to pick up on something having to do with this, although other topics are just as fair game. Others can chime in one the group has posted, as you've been doing so well.

Tuesday, February 6 (5)

bulletGroup 2 should post by 10 PM Monday night. Books 8 and 9 are as far as we'll go in Augustine's Confessions. I don't think you should have trouble finding a topic to post about.

Friday, March 16 (3)

bulletReading Milton's Paradise Lost will be a bit of an experience. You'll get better at it as you go on, but you'll also want to get to the point that you can fully imagine the scenes of the opening books: the awakening of Satan and the fallen "rebel angels" in Hell, his speech to them and the construction of "Pandaemonium" in Book I, and then the "parliament of devils" and Satan's meeting with his offspring, Sin and Death and his foray into "limitless ocean" and abyss of Night in Book II.
bulletDon't get too hung up reading footnotes. The glosses on the sides will give you meanings of many of the words, and they are more essential to a basic reading than the footnotes. Especially skip the footnotes that talk of literary influences and allusions, etc., as these aren't necessary to get the sense of the story/poem.
bulletFor your journals, focus on scenes that you like or find interesting, even if you have questions about them. Part of my goal for this book is just to get us comfortable reading it and developing a sense for the beauty and power of the language.
bulletSome of the passages are doing conventional things for epics. In Homer's Iliad, one has the catalog of all the Greek ships besieging Troy in Book I--here we get a catalog of devils, starting at about line 376, all of whom take their names from the Canaanite gods and other deities, as well as places where the Israelites battled the Philistines, Moabites, etc., in the Old Testament. So don't get too hung up on I.392-587. You get back to Satan in 587: "Their dread commander."
bulletPublic Folder: Find something that you can talk about where you feel you've got at least a solid beginning understanding. For example, the character or personality of Satan--what do you think of him? Anything surprising in Milton's portrayal of Satan? Any lines of Satan or of Moloch or Beelzebub or Belial or Mammon that strike you especially in the discussion of the devils' plans? Or anything in the description of hell itself? What about the depiction of Sin and Death? Why are they described as they are? At the same time, don't be afraid to point to places where you need some help for understanding.